VAN HALEN NEWS DESK

The Kinks vs. Van Halen

"You Really Got Me" / "Atomic Punk" 7" Single

From Hennemusic.com:

Van Halen really got to Dave Davies of The Kinks with their version of “You Really Got Me.”

In a new interview with Classic Rock magazine, The Kinks’ original lead guitarist offered his thoughts on the VH version for the first time – more than 30 years after its release.

“Van Halen’s version was very Middle America. It was like, ‘Hey man, look at me with my tight trousers! Here’s our version of You Really Got Me!,” said Davies. “There’s the thing: good art isn’t always about having the comfiest technique. I shouldn’t encourage him, but I’m sure Eddie Van Halen played better when he was drunk. But it must be a good record if people like it.”

VH’s version was like a rock supernova, launching the band’s career while turning heads everywhere with previously unheard guitar sounds courtesy of Eddie.

“You Really Got Me” was The Kinks first hit, reaching #1 in the UK in September of 1964, and top 10 in the US. Although brother Ray is credited as the sole songwriter, Dave was responsible for creating the distorted power chord sound that the song is built around. Musicologists have credited the track – and especially the power chords – as the song that “invented heavy metal,” with the tune becoming a blueprint for hard rock and heavy metal.

Interesting to note that Davies has never commented on the VH version before, and his ‘sour grapes’ approach may come from the fact that Van Halen had overshadowed the British band with its release in 1978.

“We got pissed off though, when we played America,” said Davies. “The Kinks had an album out called Low Budget [1979] and we ended up touring and playing stadiums. Some kid came up to me after one of the gigs and said: ‘I like your cover of Van Halen’s You Really Got Me.’ You have to smile sometimes.”

  • Mink

    It’s no contest. Van Halen’s version is far superior. The song is good,and you have to give Dave Davies credit for writing the song, but Van Halen took it to another level. It’s like comparing Bob Dylan’s All Along The Watchtower with Jimi Hendrix’s version. Jimi wins hands down. I feel the same way with the Kinks vs. Van Halen!

  • emarcel10

    That live Kinks version hurt my ears.
    I know I’m biased, but give me VH all day, anyday.
    Sounds like someone’s a little po’d cuz they got outshined by VH.

  • Tommy Boy

    Holy shit…really? Dave and Ray were incredible songwriters, and I’ve always respected their stuff. The Kinks should be thankful for the flattery Van Halen bestowed upon them for covering that tune (and doing it so goddamn well)…as well as quite a bit more recognition for the Kinks in the states.

  • http://heavymellowmusic.com johnny beane

    Great story and great song.
    I started playing guitar when i was 12 years old and even i knew it was a cover song.

  • Dave

    And the award for “Best Male Hip Gyration in a Music Video of 1979″ goes too…..

  • Adrian

    hahahahaha I love your cover of Van Halen’s You Really Got Me hahaha wow that sucks for them but come on guys they took the skin and bones of your song and filled it out with distortion flesh and character. And they even had all their teeth in the right place!

    P.S: What kind of asshole taunts a recovering self conscience as hell alcoholic like that? What a dick respect down on Kinks.

  • Adrian

    And p.p.s kinks as hard as you so blatantly try you will always look and sound like a semi-retarded clone of the Beatles.

  • Def B. Loud

    I think Eddie once stated in an interview, “that’s a hot tune that we turned into a jet plane”. Van Halen took it, strapped a huge pair of balls on it and served it up with a nasty, arrogant, unforgiving swagger….that’s the very essence of rock, is it not? The Kinks version made you want to dance….Van Halen’s version made You want to f@#k!!!!

  • Ryan

    Hahaha, like the comment about Eddie playing better when he is drunk!!!!!!

    The Kinks are awesome, and I enjoy their version more than Van Halen’s sometimes.

  • Aftershock

    I shouldn’t encourage him, but I’m sure Dave Davies gave better interviews when he was drunk.

    You always should give credit to the person who creates something — just as you should when someone takes what you created to entirely different level.

  • http://N/A WILLIAM JONES

    I like both. But I like Eddie’s guitar playing so much better. So much more soulful in addition to be technically more proficient!!

  • Top Jimmy

    I wonder if it burns Dave Davies ass that Van Halen did it to them again on Diver Down. VH’s version of “Where Have All The Good Times Gone” blows the Kinks out of the water… and I like the Kinks!

  • Andrew

    Ya that comment about Eddie’s drinking, real nice Dave. That’s why Ray and Dave would fight on stage! Eddie CAN play circles around Dave Davies drunk and sober!!! Ray has class his brother…….not so much!! Love ya Eddie!

  • chris

    Davies is a bitter english loser. VH took his song and made it a classic. Jealous M’F'R

  • Ryan

    I disagree. Although Van Halen’s version is very good, the Kinks version makes the hair on testicles stand up. In the three minutes it takes to hear that song, my reproductive organs have grown 1 inch. (up to 3 inches now)

  • Robert

    Mink and Aftershock: I agree with you 100%.

  • BrianG

    Bitter much? lol

  • Opusthe1

    I just get no charge out of the kinks version- its just boring to me. Whereas the VH version is pure dynamite.

  • Alex Han Valen

    There is a chef on the audience? lol minute 1:23

  • MICAL VEE

    Like eddie said about YOU REALLY GOT ME….We took a hot tune and turned it into a jet airplane!!! That shows you how great VAN HALEN was,they took a killer song and made it even better!!!

  • Jeff

    got class?

  • Fat Cat

    It probably PISSES Dave Davies OFF that he gets a BIGGER royalty check from the Van Halen version than The Kinks!!!

    Bitter, table for one!!!

  • Roth Zealot 78

    Sounds like another old, bitter British wanker who’s pissed off that a young American band took a boring Kinks song and turned it into a flaming rocketship from Hell.

    Everyone and their grandma knows that Van Halen’s version of that song is FRIGGIN’ AWESOME and gets all the chicks’ panties soppin’ wet and dudes’ cocks grow 3 inches just listening to it at max. volume (I know mine does). There is so much swagger and attitude in Van Halen’s rendition it almost explodes in a big nut wad of testosterone all over your eyes and ears!

    Dave Davies will die an angry old English twat — still mad that a bunch of Pasadena bad asses named Van Halen made his song more famous than his pathetic band ever could.

  • stew

    Adrian I’m with you what a jerk ! I wouldn’t even know that the Kinks existed without Van Halen! Eddie the greatest guitar player in the WORLD ! Sober Or Drunk ! I don”t give a damn!!!!

  • stew

    Roth Zealot I think I’ve just met by friend in the whole world ! Thats probably the best post I’ve ever read on this site . Can we have a Bromance ?

  • Atomic Pete

    He’s just upset that his brother got all the royalties (and maybe rightly so).
    Jimmy Page played on early Kinks records and is rumored
    to have played this riff but I think he has all but
    denied that it was him.

  • Ed

    LOL!! Are you kidding me Dave Davies????? You should be HONORED VH turned your song into a CLASSIC! What a D-Bag! Jealous, bitter D-bag.

  • vnhalen8

    VH’s version is SUPERIOR!!!!!!!!

  • http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jtOr65jRm0w Skutch

    The Kinks are an amazing band. Waterloo Sunset is regarded as one of the best songs ever written. People who diss the Kinks have some serious problems needing their musical tastes to be validated. If the Kinks are so lame, why did TWO of their songs end up on VH records. Comparing these bands is ridiculous because they are completely different.

  • Phlip5150

    Ok first off, Ryan, you’re an absolute moron!! You are obviously looking for an argument. Go listen to your shitty old Kinks music. You ignorant FUCK!!
    Now that’s off of my chest. Dave Davies is just an unhappy Britt and is bitter towards EVH for bringing his shitty uncolorful song to guitar god levels. Let’s face it, VH could have redone the Barney song and made kick ass!!

  • andy

    The Kinks were acting the like the Beatles for Christ sakes…. Man… Get over it…

  • Fanboy

    @Ed – Jealous, bitter D-Bag????? Who are you to insult Dave Davies?

  • freddiegirl

    I love the VH version. As far as I’m concerned VH made that tune wholly their own. Sounds like sour grapes to me.

  • the joker

    Van Halen version, always.

  • Karl

    Skutch is the first in this thread to get it: If the Kinks suck as bad as half of you claim why did VH cover two of their songs? I think Dave and Ed know what good music is and they thought the kinks worthy of two covers so maybe you all need to stop whining just because someone offered an opinion about your precious Van Halen that you don’t like.

  • Ice Cream Man

    Ahh, Mr. Davies: I’ll get you a bottle of whatever you drink. I’ll pay for the studio time. You pick out ANY VH tune to cover and see if anyone is listening to it at the end of this year let alone 30 years from now.

    Hell, straight up, Mikey’s bass is better than the original version.

  • Ryan

    Hey losers,

    Dave Davies can say whatever he wants to say, whenever he wants to. At least he didn’t turn into a salesman.

  • mean street

    Where have all the good times gone?

  • Diamond Dean

    Ray Davies deserves absolute respect for writing one of the greatest songs of all time . Dave Davies obviously missed out on the credit and is bitter n twisted n hasnt got a cent from it , poor Dave.

    VH do cover tunes better then anyone else , david lee has done some of the greatest covers of all time.

    you really got me
    ice cream man
    your no good
    where have all the good times gone
    pretty woman
    big bad bill
    dancing in the street
    happy trails
    easy street
    californian girls
    just a gigalo
    coconut grove
    im easy
    tabacco rd
    thats life
    night life

    Then there was his covers album yikes!! shoo bop is great

    Sammy did appolitical blues oh well

  • SCAR

    Skutch, you are so right brother!!!! Rock the fuck on!!!! Karl makes a good point too!!! Remember people, opinions are like assholes, everyone has one and some stink more than others!!!!!

  • lucky

    I think both versions are great and aren’t really comparable. Two different bands, different decades, different styles. Davies is obviously a bitter English douche.

  • http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jtOr65jRm0w Skutch

    I didn’t even watch the clip because I judge a band BY THEIR MUSIC. The Kinks were amazing songwriters, who cares who is a better guitar player. There’s more to music than just guitar playing.

  • Rick Pride

    I think the Kinks should be grateful. Van Halen should be thanked for turning their fans to look at the Kinks. I wonder how many people bought the original Kinks version to compare or how many bought Kinks stuff to see what Van Halen’s fascination was about. They should be anything but bitter. They should thank Eddie Van Halen

  • Panama Red

    I think Skutch summed it up pretty well.

    This article said that Dave Davies offers his thoughts on the VH version for the first time but I could’ve sworn I read recently that Davies admitted that he liked Van Halen’s version better than the Kinks. Am I crazy?

  • Nat

    If Ray is credited as the sole songwriter, he’s probably the one raking in the royalties on the VH version. Maybe that’s part of Dave’s bitterness ;-)

    I prefer the VH version, but I suppose that goes without saying since I read this site. I’m sure there are a ton of people who are big Kinks fans who think the original is MUCH better than the VH version.

    As for his “played better drunk” comment, it’s pretty low-class but the same sentiment has been made by many commenters on this site.

  • Jungleland2

    Van Halen made a LOT of money for Ray and Dave Davies. You Really Got me and Where Have All The Good Times Gone. Add The Pretender’s Stop Your Sobbing and it looks like Ray Davies was having more success with others doing his songs (at least in America). The Live Kinks LP from the early 80′s has them doing the Van Halen version of YRGM anyway! The Van Halen covers kept them in the spotlight at a time where they were NOT having hit songs (Come Dancing was 82 or 83 right?)

  • D.O.A.

    Dean

    Hi loser…just wanted to point out that VH did Apolitcal Blues. Sorry moron. Charming of you to drag your jealousy in to another post.

    Keep em coming.

    Hugs

  • http://vhnd kevin

    vh gives the song major balls

  • Darren from Staten Island

    Dear Dave Davies, Stop being so bitter and get your head out of your ass. Thanks Van Halen fans from all over the world. P.S.-In the immortal words of Spickoily “You Dick”

  • Dave

    The Kinks version actually rocks pretty good here. VH were obviously lip syncing for this video which takes away from it just a bit. Regardless, the VH version is a classic, the Kinks….forgotten.