VAN HALEN NEWS DESK

New list: Top Guitarists of All Time – Eddie Van Halen #3

From the Chop Shop radio show

Chop Shop Guitar Show Announces The Top 100 Most Complete Guitar Players
of All Time

Steve Black, host of The Chop Shop and The Chop Shop Classic, assembled a five member panel to rate and rank guitarists, resulting in The Chop Shop’s Top 100 Most Complete Guitarists Of All-Time.  The list is a complete list, as each guitarist was ranked in the following categories: technical ability, soul and emotion, influence on the music and guitar industries, song writing, live experience, sales, signature sound and longevity.  Steve and his panel very much enjoyed ranking the guitarists, and its with pride that The Chop Shop presents the results to you!

1st Place – Jimmy Page

2nd Place – Jimi Hendrix

3rd Place – Eddie Van Halen:

Place Guitarist Total

1 Jimmy Page 87.94
2 Jimi Hendrix 84.92
3 Eddie Van Halen 84.81
4 David Gilmour 82.72
5 Keith Richards 82.48
6 Pete Townshend 80.66
7 Steve Vai 79.74
8 Les Paul 78.61
9 Angus Young 78.56
10 Jeff Beck 77.77
11 Stevie Ray Vaughan 75.86
12 Tony Iommi 74.67
13 Eric Clapton 74.62
14 James Hetfield 73.62
15 Ritchie Blackmore 72.61
16 Slash 71.60
17 Frank Zappa 71.57
18 George Harrison 71.49
19 Randy Rhoads 70.89
20 Ted Nugent 70.83
21 Murray/Smith 70.72
22 Carlos Santana 70.44
23 Steve Lukather 70.41
24 Joe Satriani 69.71
25 Chuck Berry 69.53
26 Kirk Hammett 69.48
27 Zakk Wylde 68.73
28 Brian May 67.57
29 Alex Lifeson 67.51
30 Billy Gibbons 67.45
31 Malcom Young 66.56
32 Joe Perry 65.60
33 Joe Walsh 63.44
34 B.B. King 63.30
35 Kurt Cobain 63.17
36 Dimebag Darrell Abbott 62.55
37 Neal Schon 62.45
38 John Lennon 62.44
39 Mark Knopfler 62.43
40 Dickey Betts 60.47
41t Tom Scholz 60.42
41t Robby Krieger 60.42
43 Buddy Guy 60.38
44 Tom Morello 60.37
45 The Edge 60.34
46 Rossington/Collins 59.49
47 Tipton/Downing 58.64
48 Peter Frampton 58.59
49 Mick Mars 58.34
50 Steve Howe 57.36
51 John Frusciante 55.46
52 Brad Whitford 55.45
53 Scotty Moore 55.35
54 Rik Emmett 54.58
55 Yngwie Malmsteen 54.56
56 Leslie West 54.50
57 Dean DeLeo 54.46
58 Ace Frehley 54.38
59 Bo Diddley 54.37
60 Muddy Waters 54.36
61 John5 53.63
62 Gary Moore 53.55
63 Paul Gilbert 53.51
64 George Lynch 53.41
65 Adam Jones 53.20
66 Robin Trower 52.62
67t Michael Schenker 52.52
67t Johnny Winter 52.52
69 Michael Hedges 52.40
70 Robert Johnson 52.36
71 Dave Mustaine 52.34
72 Warren DiMartini 51.49
73 Dave Davies 51.36
74 Nuno Bettencourt 50.52
75 Mark Tremonti 50.40
76 Dan Donegan 50.39
77t Warren Haynes 50.36
77t Matthias Jabbs 50.36
79 Freddie King 50.33
80 DeGarmo/Wilton 50.28
81t Neil Young 50.23
81t Steve Cropper 50.23
83 Frank Marino 49.51
84 Ty Tabor 49.46
85 Eric Johnson 49.44
86 Mike McCready 49.34
87 Steve Miller 49.33
88 John Fogerty 49.26
89 John Sykes 49.20
90 Vivian Campbell 48.41
91t Dick Wagner 48.40
91t Kim Thayil 48.40
93 Jerry Cantrell 48.28
94 Glen Buxton 47.55
95 Rick Nielsen 47.44
96 Rod Price 47.41
97t Frank Hannon 47.38
97t Buckethead 47.38
99 Steve Stevens 47.36
100 Trevor Rabin 47.36

We welcome your comments and questions about the list…send them to:
black@chopshopradio.com

  • lollypop

    Mick Mars (nothing against him) before Y. Malmsteen…no comments

  • jmd

    Page number 1? Top 10, yes.
    No clapton? No SRV?
    This list is suspect.

  • Michael

    These lists are always debatable, so I’m not gonna complain….too much. But c,mon. Is there really 54 guitarists better than Yngwie? Pete Townshend and David Gilmour are better than Steve Vai??? I dare someone to name me one song by Les Paul.Using the info that they discussed, Steve is every bit as qualified as the top three. And technically, he’s by far the most complete. I always think there’s too much emphasis on popularity. David Gilmour, Pete Townshend and Keith Richards are all fine guitarists with long music backgrounds, but they are not, in my opinion even in the same league as Jimi, Jimmy, Eddie or Steve.

  • Ray

    Jimmy Page @ #1? I don’t agree with THAT! Michael said it best, these lists are always debatable and there are ALWAYS players missing.

  • Mike

    Thought Sammy would make it at least in the 90′s!!

  • Rafael

    Ok for TOP4. But Richards is complete out of being ‘complete’. And where is Petrucci ??? Some will say: “Oh no, Petrucci is totaly technical, where is the feeling”. And I should answer: “Do you want a ‘complete’ guitar player (including composer) or a pentatonic one ???”
    Greeting from Brazil!

  • Coyoteface

    I don’t see the point of lists like these. I love a whole bunch of the guitar players on this list, yet it never crossed my mind to rank them. 1,000 people, 1,000 different lists and so far there hasn’t been one list that made me reconsider my own taste in guitar playing and sounds.

  • tim

    the list is bs.

    where is satriani. i am a big evh fan, but satriani is arguably the best guitar player on the planet.

    where is neal schon?

    SRV?

    KWS?

  • Buckaloo

    No discussion about it.
    All of us have our own preferences, but, there’s no doubt about the following:
    Number 1 – Mr. Edward Van Halen; (He on heaven and Vai on earth)
    Number 2 – Mr. Vai.

    The other, only bad copies.

    That’s all folks.

    Greetings from São Paulo, Brasil.

  • sad fan

    EVERYONES GOT AN OPINION.THE NEWS DESK NEEDS TO DO SOME RESEARCH ABOUT THAT SUPPOSED LIVE DVD OF THE LAST TOUR.

  • theREALchris

    Page. No Quarter live. Nuff said.

  • David Alexander

    By these criteria E Van Halen beats Jimmy Page.

    Technical ability – Van Halen. Jimmy could never do the two handed playing Eddie does.

    Soul and emotion – Page – Toss up, both have it, but Page’s songs are more “emotional”. Page

    Influence on the music and guitar industries – Van Halen – Hands down Eddie Van Halen has done more than ANY guitarist in terms of influencing the guitar industry. His striped, homemade guitar is an icon. He single handedly popularized the single humbucking pickup with a Floyd rose setup. And with the production of his own guitars.

    Song writing _ Jimmy Page

    Live experience – Eddie Van Halen is a more dynamic performer on stage.

    Sales- Jimmy Page. Zeps sales are staggering.

    Signature sound- HANDS DOWN Eddie Van Halen, probably the most coveted and unattainable sound. Early “brown sound”. Pages sound is easily recreated.

    Longevity = Eddie Van Halen has put out more albums and toured longer than Page has. Page has had many years with no output or touring.

    Tech Ability – Van Halen
    Soul/Emotion – Page
    Influence – Van Halen
    Song Writing – Page
    Live Experience – Van Halen
    Sales – Page
    Longevity – Van Halen

    Van Halen wins 4-3

  • pushtoshove

    Who cares about these BS lists anyways??!! HAHAHAHA….You know who’s number one on my list? ME !!! And anyone who isn’t current or not recording and putting out product is a has been…..Today is today and yesterday is but a memory….Right here right now there is NO GOOD ROCK MUSIC

  • David Alexander

    Mick Mars better than Ace Frehley??!?!

    Have you not heard Kiss Alive?? Ace Frehley is a rock guitar icon.

    Ace is also better than Nugent.

    Joe Perry is better than Nugent too.

  • David Alexander

    Ace Frehley and Joe Perry are both better than James Hetfield.

  • Mark Johnson

    Steve Vai is ranked higher than Eric Clapton? Steve Vai is ranked at all?

  • Michael

    David Alexander…are you serious???!! Being on this site, you obviously have appreciation for good music and musicians. Do you really thing Steve Vai is not even talented, much less one of the best there is? I’m interested to hear your reply and reasons behind it.

  • Michael

    Not David Alexander….Mark Johnson…my apologies.

  • Kevin

    David Alexander lol i came to comment on the exact same thing before i read that you already did. Also in terms of longevity, Eddie is almost perfect compared to what he used to be; his skill is diminished about 0.1%. When i saw them in 2007, he was absolutely FLAWLESS. Whereas the Led Zep O2 Show, did you listen to the solo in Stairway to Heaven? Totally butchered. Nothing against Jimmy Page, though, he’s fantastic. But yeah EVH all the way.

  • Gee Lopz

    KURT COBAIN on the top 100 guitar players????
    What the hell is this?? Are you kidding???
    Eddie is my favorite…But the real BIG ONES (in influence to ALL guitar players) is 1. Hendrix, 2. Eddie Van Halen, 3. Jimmy Page, 4. Eric Clapton. …

    I like Vai, Satriani, Paul Gilbert, Malmsteen, Adrian Smith, Dave Murray, Zakk Wilde, Dimebag Darrel…,but this guys don´t “exist” without EVH, Hendrix, Clapton, Blackmore, Page, Iommi…

    C´mon!!??? Kurt Cobain?? Mike McCready??? NO, NO, NO, NO !!!!! This guys are not guitarists!! Ok, BAD guitar players…

    Trevor Rabin (a HUGE guitar player!!) on 100º????

  • http://www.freewebs.com/maelstromcustoms/index.htm MAELSTROM

    YAAAAWWWN….another top ten list…

    So 5 guys put this together? Well, any combination of 5 different guys would have a totally different list, although not many people I know would place Dave Gilmour, and Keith Richards in the top 20, much less put them before Eric Clapton (#13-HUH?), Joe Walsh (#33), Stevie Ray Vaughn (#11-WTF?), Leslie West (#56), or even the highly underrated Steve Stevens (#99) on this list…I know, I know, this is a list compiled with certain categories and criteria taken into account…yada, yada, yada…

  • mack

    eddie van halen s the greatest guitarist to ever walk the planet earth and the most copied enough said

  • pushtoshove

    THERE IS NO GOOD ROCK MUSIC TODAY. PERIOD.

  • pushtoshove

    SORRY. A C / D C IS THE EXCEPTION.

  • alexandre

    Eddie Van Halen made history playng Beat it on Michael Jackson’s “Thriller”, besides all great music he made with his band. For me he is the number one!!

  • David C

    If you can’t name a Les Paul song…..you need to go listen to him and not look ignorant on a blog.
    Les Paul is the Daddy of all of us…92 years old and still plays a gig every Monday night in New York. The whole list aside – Les Paul is the man!!

  • pushtoshove

    So..how is this list compiled?….Lets see…on how good a guitarist is Live?…How good he is in the studio?…how many hit records he has had?…how current he is?…how good his technique is?…how innovative he is?…how many arenas he has sold out?…how he learned?…how influential he is?…There are way too many things to base this on in order for it to be a valid list…I knew plenty of GREAT guitarists when i was growing up in the late seventy’s and early to mid eighty’s and most of them are either dead , happily married or incarcerated …and none of the are in this so called “list”….This is a popularity contest …no more no less.

  • JD Miller

    wait! 3?
    Really!
    He WAS 2!
    I dont get it, he is one or two.
    NOT THREE.
    thats bs.

  • Phil

    A lot of that list is suspect. Zappa should’ve rated muuuuch higher. I’d personally like to kill the guy that thinks Angus Young is a better guitarist than Zappa.
    Whatev, as long as Page rates higher than Ed. Love ya Ed, but tough shit, Page has always been and will always be better.
    These lists are such moronic garbage anyway, it’s all subjective. So why am I responding to this? Because I’m that bored, that’s why.

  • ou812

    81t Neil Young 38 John Lennon

  • Alex

    what the hell?

    this is just another shit list. james hetfield going before kirk? what the fuck is that? this list just doesn’t make sense for one.

    for two, i don’t need a god damn list to tell me who’s the best guitarist, for fuck’s sake people, the best guitarist isn’t debatable. or listable. it’s YOU’RE OWN opinion, so stick to your own mind.

  • rockquest

    Again Alex Skolnik is missing!

  • Ted

    This list is ridiculous. It’s mostly shred players.

  • Rus Man

    Richards, Young in the top 10?

    I would never question their “commercial success” but to be considered a top 10 “greatest” guitarist is a stretch to say the least…

    Most of these polls are really based on personal preference.

    I don’t like Yngwie or his music but he should have ranked significantly higher. The reason he wasn’t is because those voting aren’t familiar with his music.

    Adding someone to the list ends up being “the right thing to do”… We’ve gotta drop Yngwie in here somewhere?

    I would have liked to have been a fly on the wall when they talked about Prince and his place on the chart?

    I’d say those “right ones” end up starting at 20 back.

  • Massimo Anelli

    I don’t know who deserve to be from place number two to the last one, but i’m sure “who” must be and stay on the first one! Mr Eddie VAN HALEN ladies and gentlemen. A huge fan from Italy

  • http://vanhalennews anita nutt

    what about steve morse, albert lee. eric johnson plays circles around just about everybody. is this list on album sales?

  • Flying Dutchman

    …And what about Tony MacAlpine and Vinnie Moore? I think these are two great guitar players….

  • Amad Ali

    I think most of you have contributed some really good comments. But let me contribute as well. I think that the top three names listed is is arguably correct – not the ordering, but I think that it’s safe to say that the top three do belong there. I’ll even go as far as to say that Hendrix appropriately belongs in the top ten, but not the top three. But again, as many of you have said, this list seems to be suspect: there are a hand full of names on this whole list that have no business being anywhere around the top 25. I need not say anything more specific on that, in part because enough of you have already elaborated on those particular guitarists. But let’s get some things straight here, and I apologize if I come off rude, but I feel very strongly about this. Although Ed Van Halen is quite popular, he nevertheless, and ironically, is still under rated. Much of this has to do with the soap opera that has taken place with the band, but I also think that it has to do with the mainstream type of mind that really has difficulty digesting the absolute genious of this guy. As David Alexander said above, “Signature sound- HANDS DOWN Eddie Van Halen, probably the most coveted and unattainable sound. Early “brown sound”. Pages sound is easily recreated.” People in the West love the Blues and they should because it is great. However, I think that Ed Van Halen combined his classical and blues roots with an amazing innovation that has yet to be surpassed. The blues will always be loved, but Ed’s innovation and work, and thus those who trully understand his sound, will be marveled and jaw dropping to generations way ahead of us.
    Sorry so long here, but I usually don’t have folks to talk with about this stuff.

  • theREALchris

    Good point about Prince…..he’s probably one of the most underrated guitarits.

  • TheReddman

    I was surprised to see clapton out of the top 10…..eddie and jimi were a virtual tie……a few misplacements throughout but one of the best lists ive seen in awhile….hopefully eddie will create some of his magic for all of us to hear real soon…..

  • Paul Bevilacqua

    Nothing worng with that list – top three are without a doubt the Kings. I’m glad to see Neal Shcon on the list; there’s a cat that doesn’t get enough credit. A very melodic player, doesn’t overplay all the time, can definaltey shred, and I think his sound is one of the best in the buisness.

  • Rob Morton

    As has already been said…list is subjective…lot of good talent…must admit I too was surprised that Mr. Hagar did not place somewhere low on the list…some of you may think I’m whacked in the head… but, I think Brian Setzer deserves to be on the list also

  • Chenny Kesney

    Alright where the hell is Synyster Gates

  • iwannaberr

    I agree with everyone about the ultimate comment – this list is incorrect! You could rotate the top 3 in those positions and you’d be right. EVH is my #1 mostly because he invented and mainstreamed all of it. However, there is a guy that is also talented and plays cleaner than EVH – SATRIANI! Steve Vai over Satriani??? Hetfield over Satriani??? Iommi over Satriani?? Malcolm Young? (he’s a rythm guitarist) Come on! I agree that Sammy should be in the top 100.

  • Joel

    I agree with the top 10, except for one thing….SCORCH RIDDLIN from The Gods Of Rock should be at least top 3. He bleeds Rock.

    Otherwise, great job.

  • MikeBass

    At least this list makes more sense than the “SHIT” list Rolling Stone Magazine came up with.
    Anyone who thinks RS is a credible mag is a F*cking Moron.
    They are retarded and should have there eyes gouged out, ears stabbed with an ice pick and tongue pulled out with a fork.
    Can you tell I “LOATHE” Rolling Stone Magazine?

  • Adrian

    Opinions are like assholes…….everybody’s got one!
    Ranking lists are pointless.
    Measure these guyz by their album sales, ticket sales, grammy awards, whatever – you might get a ranking, but would you really “change” your favourite guitar player ‘cos another guy sold 1000 records more???
    So, fellas…….what do we care, anyway?
    Let’s get back to work!

  • http://na John Greggs

    who would I rather hear live? THAT`S how I grade a guitar player!…..Keith Richards would be the first, second would be Clapton, third would be Chuck Berry…then Van Halen, Alex Lifeson,……there is no one after Alex

  • Phlip5150

    Ok, Steve Vai. Is he technical? Yes but his stuff is not memerable at all. Being able to play fast and stuff doesn’t make a great guitarist. IT’s what you do with what you know, THAT’S what makes a great guitarist. What has Vai done for music? Nothing, that’s what. Can anyone name one song of his not being a fan? I don’t think so.

  • Chris Lowe

    Brain May at 28. This is a joke. Top 5. Keith Richards sucks.